QUESTION OF THE WEEK, TIED INTO THIS RACHEL BOLAN STORY, NAME A SONG YOU THINK IS PERFECTLY CRAFTED?

In a new interview with “Mistress Carrie” Sarao of The Mistress Carrie PodcastSkid Row bassist Rachel Bolan was asked to name a song from any other artist that he thinks is “perfectly crafted”.

He responded (as transcribed by blabbermouth.net), “There’s a couple. Lido Shuffle [by] Boz Scaggs. There’s nothing that isn’t amazing about that song as a body of work. Every time I listen to it, I’m, like, ‘Wow, where did this come from?’ I don’t know if I would be able to create something like that. And then the other is Breakdown by Tom Petty And The Heartbreakers. That’s just one of those songs, even though it has that false start which kind of makes it even more amazing and beautiful — the structure of that song is so bizarre. It’s almost like it’s unfinished. But it’s such an incredible song ’cause from the minute it starts, it’s like, ‘Yep, breakdown. Cool.’ And then, before you know it, it’s gone. But that’s one of those songs that I wish I wrote. Simplicity.”

After Mistress Carrie noted that the hardest songs to write are usually the simplest ones, Bolan concurred. “I agree,” he said. “I write simple. And I guess that’s just the stuff I listen to. Most of the stuff I listened to was three-chord rock: KISS, AC/DCRamonesSex Pistols, for the most part. And so that is kind of in my wiring to write like that, I guess. And that’s the only thing I know…”

[Dana’s comment: I will have to think about this, since there are so many great songs, but as of my typing this, The Beatles were the kings of writing catchy, simple songs.]

23 Responses

  1. Well, according to the late, great Davis Allen Coe, John Prine and Steve Goodman wrote the perfect country song. You Never Even Called Me by My Name.

  2. Here are a few that come to mind:
    Ozzy- You Can’t Kill Rock and Roll
    Skid Row- I’ll Remember You
    Rush- Limelight
    Social Distortion- Bad Luck
    AC/DC- TNT
    Badfinger- Day After Day

  3. Elton John….Your Song / Daniel / The Greatest Discovery / High Flying Bird / Harmony …….take your pick with classic Elton
    Journey….Still They Ride
    Beatles….Yesterday / Long and Winding Road
    Yes…Roundabout
    James Taylor….There We Are / Baby Boom Baby
    Billy Joel….Leave a Tender Moment Alone
    Don Henley…Heart of the Matter / Boys of Summer / End of Innocence
    Fleetwood Mac…. Landslide
    Sting… Fragile / Fields of Gold

Leave a Reply