BASSIST MICHAEL ANTHONY ADDRESSES THE RUMOR THAT SINGER PATTY SMYTH WAS CONSIDERED AS A REPLACEMENT FOR DAVID LEE ROTH IN VAN HALEN

During a November 15th question-and-answer session at this month’s Rock ‘N’ Roll Fantasy Camp in Hollywood, California, former Van Halen bassist Michael Anthony addressed the rumor that Sammy Hagar was not the band’s first choice to replace David Lee Roth when Van Halen parted ways with the frontman in 1985. Guitarist Eddie Van Halen reportedly asked Patty Smyth of the group Scandal to join the band first.

When asked if there was any validity to the gossip, Anthony said (as transcribed by blabbermouth.net),  ”You’re getting into kind of a gray area there. Patty Smyth actually was considered at one point. And this was Ed. When Dave left, it kind of threw us all in a bit of a tailspin. [Our record label] Warner Brothers, they wanted us to change the name of the band right away, hoping that one day Dave would come back, and we could resume the Van Halen thing. But it was kind of like the fairy tale was over, the initial success that we had with the band. And Ed, he was kind of freaking out a bit. And there were quite a few people that either jammed with us, or Ed had spoken to, so we really didn’t know. We all kind of decided [in the end that] we didn’t need Patty Smyth to come in, having a girl come in singing songs about girls. It wasn’t gonna fit.”

When probed if any other singers were considered for the position over the years, Anthony recalled, “There’s a guy by the name of Mitch Malloy. Anybody remember him? I just did a show in Vegas [Sally Steele‘s eighth Vegas Rocks! Magazine Music Awards, which took place on September 20th at The Orleans Showroom at The Orleans Hotel & Casino]…. This girl Sally Steele has an award show in Vegas every year. And they wanted me to come up and jam at the end, and they said, ‘Well, Mitch Malloy‘s gonna be there.’ And he had actually met with Ed and [drummer] Al[ex] [Van Halen]. He sang on some stuff that Ed had written, but it was kind of a real short-lived deal. He thought that he was gonna be in the band, and then all of a sudden Gary Cherone… It was kind of a weird type of deal.”

Back in July 2020, Smyth told Stereogum about being asked to join Van Halen. She said, “They were heavy drinkers. I don’t drink. I never saw myself living in L.A. I was, like, ‘I’m from New York. We don’t move to L.A.’

“It’s all semantics because if [Eddie] had said to me, ‘Let’s make a record,’ then I would have said yes to that. But joining the band — to me then, ‘Oh god, they fight all the time, him and his brother, and I don’t want to get into a volatile situation.’ And I was probably heavily hormoned out because I was eight months pregnant, so there was a state of mind that I was in of how I need to take care of myself. But I regretted turning him down. For a long time, I regretted it. When you start to have regrets, I was, like, ‘Oh, man. I would’ve made so much money.'”

Asked if she thinks her prior negative experience in a group dynamic might have given her pause to join another way more publicly rambunctious band, she said, “Yeah, that definitely has something to do with it. I’m sure. And also just the fact that it was, like, ‘I’m going to have to move to L.A.’ I should have just had the conversation [with Eddie]. It was such a weird conversation. But if he had said to me, ‘Look, just come out for a few months and make a record. Have the baby, come out and let’s make a record.’ That to me would’ve been more doable.

And I never said anything about it for years. I got a call from Ed, and he was, like, ‘Look, I’m not saying that I asked you to join because I don’t want Sammy Hagar to look like [he was] second choice,’ and I was, like, ‘Okay.’ So I never spoke about it after that. I’m, like, all right I don’t need to tell people. If someone asked me, I didn’t lie but I didn’t really talk about it that much.”

Scandal, which had several hits in the ’80s, the two most recognizable being, Goodbye To You and The Warrior, broke up after and Smyth went on to record as a solo act.

Van Halen eventually recruited Hagar, who sang on four studio albums between 1986 and 1995 before he quit the group in 1996. Hagar rejoined for a 2004 tour but left again after that, paving the way for the final reunion with Roth, which began in 2007 with a world tour.

Fan filmed footage of Anthony‘s question and answer session at Rock ‘N’ Roll Fantasy Camp appears below.

One Response

  1. Hello? Why wasn’t Anthony asked about Daryl Hall? Hall was actually approached by EVH first before Smyth, Love Hall’s voice, but I can’t imagine what Eddie was smoking, drinking and thinking?! Lol! My favorite Scandal songs are “Love’s Got A Line On you,” and “Beat Of A Heart,” but Smyth (just like Hall) definitely would not have fit in with Van Halen!

Leave a Reply